nLab Kaluza-Klein mechanism

Contents

Phenomenology

Differential geometry

synthetic differential geometry

Introductions

from point-set topology to differentiable manifolds

Differentials

V-manifolds

smooth space

Tangency

The magic algebraic facts

Theorems

Axiomatics

cohesion

tangent cohesion

differential cohesion

$\array{ && id &\dashv& id \\ && \vee && \vee \\ &\stackrel{fermionic}{}& \rightrightarrows &\dashv& \rightsquigarrow & \stackrel{bosonic}{} \\ && \bot && \bot \\ &\stackrel{bosonic}{} & \rightsquigarrow &\dashv& \mathrm{R}\!\!\mathrm{h} & \stackrel{rheonomic}{} \\ && \vee && \vee \\ &\stackrel{reduced}{} & \Re &\dashv& \Im & \stackrel{infinitesimal}{} \\ && \bot && \bot \\ &\stackrel{infinitesimal}{}& \Im &\dashv& \& & \stackrel{\text{étale}}{} \\ && \vee && \vee \\ &\stackrel{cohesive}{}& ʃ &\dashv& \flat & \stackrel{discrete}{} \\ && \bot && \bot \\ &\stackrel{discrete}{}& \flat &\dashv& \sharp & \stackrel{continuous}{} \\ && \vee && \vee \\ && \emptyset &\dashv& \ast }$

Models

Lie theory, ∞-Lie theory

differential equations, variational calculus

Chern-Weil theory, ∞-Chern-Weil theory

Cartan geometry (super, higher)

Contents

Idea

The Kaluza-Klein mechanism, named after Theodor Kaluza and Oskar Klein, is the observation that pure gravity on a product spacetime $X \times F$ with fixed metric $g_F$ on $F$ looks on $X$, as an effective field theory, like gravity coupled to Yang-Mills theoryEinstein-Yang-Mills theory – for gauge group $G$ the Lie group of isometries of $(F,g_F)$. In particular for $F = S^1$ the circle, it yields electromagnetism coupled to gravity (a “graviphotonfield, but in addition also a dilaton) – Einstein-Maxwell theory.

When applied to supergravity then this mechanism produces not just force fields but also fermionic matter in the resulting effective field theory, hence yields Einstein-Yang-Mills-Dirac theory, see the examples below at KK-reduction of 11d Supergravity. As such the KK-mechanism is not unlike the idea of geometrodynamics, according to which fundamentally there is only dynamical spacetime geometry in the form of gravity with all matter and other forces being special incarnations of this.

Since in general relativity also the size and shape of the fiber $F$ is dynamical, generically effective field theories arising from KK-compactification contain spurious fields parameterizing the geometry of $F$. In the simplest case this is just the dilaton, encoding the total volume of $F$, more generally these fields are often called the moduli fields. Since these moduli fields are not observed in experiment, naive KK-models are generically phenomenologically unviable. However, in variants of gravity such as higher dimensional supergravity there are possibilities for the moduli to obtain masses and hence for the KK-models to become viable after all. This is the problem of moduli stabilization.

The mechanism

More precisely, the Einstein-Hilbert action functional on pseudo-Riemannian metrics on a product spacetime $X \times F$

$g_{X \times F} \;\mapsto\; S_{EH}(g_{X \times F}) \;\coloneqq\; \int_{X \times F} R(g_{X \times F}) \, dvol(g_{X \times F})$

when restricted to pseudo-Riemannian metrics of the special form

$\left(g^{KK}_{X \times F} \left(x,f\right) \right) \;\in \; Sym^2\left(\Gamma\left(T^* X \times F\right)\right) \;=\; \left( \array{ g_F(f) & A^a(x)k_a \\ A^a(x) k_a & g_X(x) } \right) \,,$

where $\{k_a \in \Gamma(T F)\}$ are a basis for the Killing vector fields of $(F,g_F)$, is equivalently rewritten as

$S_{EH}\left(g^KK_{X \times F}\right) = S_{EH}\left(g_X\right) + S_{YM}(A) + S_{mod}\left(g_F\right) \,,$

where

More generally, one observes that the infinitesimal transformation of metrics $g_{X \times F}$ of the above form under diffeomorphisms generated by a Killing vector field $(x,f) \mapsto \lambda^a(x) k_a(f)$ is given on the $A$-component as follows:

$\frac{d}{d \epsilon} A = d_X \lambda^a + [\lambda,A] \,.$

This is the infinitesimal form of a gauge transformation: an isomorphism in the groupoid of Lie algebra-valued forms. This means than every functional $(g_{X \times F}) \mapsto S(g_{X\times F})$ that is invariant under diffeomorphisms will restrict on metrics of the above form to something that looks like an action functional for a gauge theory of the gauge field $A$.

Moreover, all this of course remains true if the product $X \times F$ – which we may think of as the trivial $F$-fiber bundle over $X$ – is generalized to any associated bundle $E \to X$ with fiber $F$, associated to a $G$-principal bundle $P \to X$ (hence such that $E = P \times_G F$), in which case the above decomposition of the metric applies locally.

Then one finds that the KK-mechanics indeed not only reproduces gauge fields and their correct dynamics from pure gravity in higher dimensions, but also the forces which they excert on test particles. For instance the trajectory of a charged particle subject to the Lorentz force exerted by an electromagnetic field in $d$-dimensional spacetime is in fact a geodesic in the field of pure gravity of the total space of the corresponding KK-un-compactified circle principal bundle. See (Bleecker 81) or (Bartlett 13) for a pedagogical discussion of this effect.

A pseudo-Riemannian manifold of this form $\left(E, g^KK_{E}\right)$ for fixed moduli $g_F$ is called a Kaluza-Klein compactification of the spacetime $E$. One also speaks of the effective spacetime $X$ as being obtained by dimensional reduction from the spacetime $E$.

(Beware that the term “compactification” here is vaguely related to but rather different from the use of the term in mathematics, as in one-point compactification etc.).

Its application in theoretical physics

Various evident generalizations of this ansatz can and are being considered.

Most notably for actual model building in physics it is of interest to consider the case where $g_{X}$ and $A$ are not necessarily constant along the fiber $F$. Typically in applications these fields are expanded in terms of Fourier modes on $F$. The coefficients of the higher modes appear as massive fields in the effective KK-action functional. They are called the higher Kaluza-Klein modes . These masses are inversely proportional to the metric volume of $F$. For physical model building this volume is therefore chosen to be very small, such that it implies that the model does not predict the observation of the quanta of these massive modes in existing accelerator experiments (such as the LHC).

On the other hand, the extra moduli fields $g_F$ do not acquire effective masses on $X$ this way. Therefore models in plain Kaluza-Klein theory are trivially ruled out by experiment: for any choice of $F$ they predicts the observation on $X$ of these massless moduli fields, which however are not being seen in actual accelerator experiments.

Therefore if in a model for fundamental physics the Kaluza-Klein mechanism is invoked as a way to explain the existence of the standard model of particle physics in Yang-Mills theory from pure gravity, then the setup needs to be further generalized: other ingredients of the model need to be introduced that serve to equip the moduli fields with an effective potential with a positive minimum, such that these fields to acquire an effective mass on $X$.

In physics model building the problem of constructing such a more general KK-model is called the moduli stabilization problem . (See also at landscape of string theory vacua.)

Formalization

KK-compactification along trivial fibrations is closely related to forming mapping stacks: if $\mathbf{Fields}_n$ is the moduli stack of fields] for an $n$-dimensional field theory (see at prequantum field theory for more on this), then for $\Sigma_{k}$ a $k$-dimensional manifold with $k \lt n$ the mapping stack

$\mathbf{Fields}_{n-k} \coloneqq [\Sigma_k, \mathbf{Fields}]$

may be thought of as the moduli stack of fields for an $(n-k)$-dimensional field theory. By the definition universal property of the mapping stack, this lower dimensional field theory is then such that a field configiuration over an $(n-k)$-dimensional spacetime $X_{n-k}$

$\phi \colon X_{n-k} \longrightarrow \mathbf{Fields}_{n-k}$

is equivalently a field configuration of the $n$-dimensional field theory

$X_{n-k} \times \Sigma_k \longrightarrow \mathbf{Fields}_n$

on the product space $X_{n-k}\times \Sigma_k$ (the trivial $\Sigma_{k}$-fiber bundle over $X_{n-k}$).

Traditionally KK-reduction is understood as retaining only parts of $\mathbf{Fields}_{n-k}$ (the “0-modes” of fields on $\Sigma_k$ only) but of course one may consider arbitrary corrections to this picture and eventially retain the full information.

One example of KK-reduction where the full mapping stack appears is the reduction of topologically twisted N=4 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory on a complex curve $C$ as it appears in the explanation of geometric Langlands duality as a special case of S-duality (Witten 08, section 6). Here $\mathbf{Fields}_4 = \mathbf{B}G_{\mathrm{conn}}$ is the universal moduli stack of $G$-principal connections (or rther that of $G$-Higgs bundles).

Examples

Reductions of pure gravity with realistic gauge groups

The gauge group of the experimentally verified standard model of particle physics is a quotient of the product of the special unitary groups $SU(3)$ and $SU(2)$ and the circle group $U(1)$.

In (Witten 81) it was observed that the minimal dimension of a fiber $F$ for the KK-reduction to yield the gauge group $SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1)$ is $d_F = 7$ . This may be a meaningless numerical coincidence, but might be – and was regarded as being – remarkable: because it means that the minimum total dimension of a KK-compactification $X \times F$ that could yield a realistic model of observed physics is $4 + 7 = 11$. This is the uniquely specified dimensional of the maximal supergravity model: 11-dimensional supergravity.

While there are many 7-dimensional manifolds $F$ that do yield the desired gauge group of the standard model, Witten 81 also shows that for none of them does the remaining field content of the standard model – the fermions and the Higgs field – come out correctly, due to lack of chiral fermions.

Largely due to this result, the original pure Kaluza-Klein ansatz that starts with just pure Einstein gravity with no other fields) is nowadays regarded as non-viable route towards the standard model of particle physics. But one can further play with the idea and consider more flexible models that still exhibit the essence of KK-reduction in parts.

Notably the 11-dimensional supergravity mentioned above contains more fields than just the field of gravity. Specifically it contains the supergravity C-field which is a higher analog of the electromagnetic field. KK-reductions of 11-dimensional supergravity and of its conjectured M-theory UV-completion for instance on G2-manifold fibers turn out to be able to yield models which come at least very close to the standard model of particle physics when considered on orbifold spacetimes. This we come to below, see also at duality between M-theory and type IIA string theory.

Reductions of type II supergravity

Motivation for further variants of the KK-ansatz has to a large extent come from models in string theory. During the end of the 20th and the beginning of the 21st century, the widely dominant ansatz followed in the higher energy physics community is to study 10-dimensional type II supergravity models KK-reduced on 6-dimensional Calabi-Yau spaces $F$. (See also at supersymmetry and Calabi-Yau manifolds.)

The advantage of these type II models is that they naturally involve further higher gauge fields, called the B-field and the RR-field. These are modeled by cocycles in ordinary differential cohomology and in differential K-theory, respectively, which means that their field strength $\mathcal{F}$ is an inhomogeneous closed differential form of even or of odd degree. Moreover, restricted to configurations $\mathcal{F}$ of these forms with specified cycles in the fiber $F$, the moduli part of the KK-reduced action functional

$(g^KK, F) \mapsto S_{EH}(g_X) + S_{YM}(A) + S_{mod}(g_F, \mathcal{F})$

does produce the previously missing positive potentials for $g_F$ proportional to these cycles of $\mathcal{F}$. So KK-reduction of 10-dimensional supergravities can – for a suitable ansatz – cure the old problem of moduli stabilization in KK-theory.

This means that physical model building using the specific ansatz of KK-reduction of type II supergravities on Calabi-Yau fibers reduces to a noteworthy enumerative problem in complex geometry: classify all real 6-dimensional Calabi-Yau manifolds with given isometries and given cycles.

While interesting, there are few tools known for performing this classification. The only thing that seems to be clear is that the classification is not sparse: there are many points in this space of choices. Since all this is relevant in model building in string theory, the space of these choices has been termed the landscape of string theory vacua.

KK-Reduction of 11d supergravity

The lift of the above reduction of type IIA supergravity on Calabi-Yau manifolds to M-theory is the KK-reduction of 11-dimensional supergravity/M-theory on G2-manifolds $X_7$. The role of the B-field and RR-field is now played by the supergravity C-field, a higher gauge field in twisted ordinary differential cohomology of degree 3+1. For non-vanishing field strength (“flux”) of the supergravity C-field in the 4d space this is the Freund-Rubin compactification yielding weak G2 holonomy on $X_7$.

Such KK-compactification of the form M-theory on G2-manifolds turn out to yield very detailed and at least semi-realistic physics, see for instance the G2-MSSM model.

The 1-form gauge field induced by KK-compactification of M-theory on a circle is the potential of the degree-2 part of the RR-field of type IIA string theory which couples to the D0-brane.

Followed by a T-duality operations these compactifications yields type IIB superstring theory compactifications and this route is known as F-theory:

F-theory KK-compactified on elliptically fibered complex analytic fiber $\Sigma$

$dim_{\mathbb{C}}(\Sigma)$1234
F-theoryF-theory on CY2F-theory on CY3F-theory on CY4

High codimension compactification of $D=10$ super Yang-Mills

The KK-compactification of D=10 super Yang-Mills theory to $D=1$ is related to what is called the BFSS matrix model. Compactification even further down to $D = 0$ gives the IKKT matrix model.

Apart from possibly producing phenomenologically interesting models from UV-complete fundamental theories on higher dimensional spacetimes, KK-reduction generally serves to connect a wide range of quantum field theories with each other in a way that serves to illuminate their general structure and to map the moduli space of all of them.

For instance various deep but rather mysterious properties of 4-dimensional Yang-Mills theory (the central theory of the standard model of particle physics), or at least of its supersymmetric versions N=1 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory/N=2 D=4 sYM/N=4 D=4 sYM, find their natural geometric interpretation by understanding this 4d theory as the KK-compactification of the 6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT on a torus fiber. Notably the Montonen-Olive duality/S-duality of N=2 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory is the conformal transformation remnant of the compactification torus remaining of the conformal invariant of the 6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT (see there for more on this).

At the same time, the 6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT is itself related to a yet higher dimensional theory, namely to a 7d Chern-Simons theory, not by KK-reduction, but by AdS-CFT duality. But that 7d Chern-Simons theory in turn is the KK-reduction of the 11-dimensional Chern-Simons term in 11-dimensional supergravity. Hence all this structure follows again from the maximal dimensional supergravity theory (M-theory) if in addition to KK-reduction one also considers AdS-CFT-boundary relations.

In an analogous way, the supersymmetric version of 4-dimensional Yang-Mills theory with twice that supersymmetry, namely N=4 D=4 sYM, is itself directly related by AdS-CFT to type II supergravity.

And this process continues further down in dimension: N=2 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory and N=4 D=4 sYM themselves have further KK-reductions to 2-dimensional field theories. For $N = 4$ and after passing to the topologically twisted theory, these are an A-model and a B-model topological string TCFT, respectively. Now what used to be S-duality/Montonen-Olive duality in 4d and conformal invariance in 6d and topological invariant in 7d and 11d here becomes geometric Langlands duality in 2d (see there for more on this) and produces Donaldson theory.

Hence by iteratively applying KK-reductions and other dualities and topological twists, one finds long cascades of different quantum field theories that all superficially look very different, but which thereby become closely related as different aspects of one single higher dimensional field theory. Not all of these lower dimensional theories can be phenomenological viable models, but even the superficially “unrealistic” theories such as the 6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT serve, via KK-reduction, to explain and illuminate deep properties of (semi-)realistic theories such as super Yang-Mills theory in 4d.

The following table displays parts of this cascade of field theories which are induced from 11-dimensional supergravity/M-theory under iterative KK-reduction, AdS-CFT duality and topological twists. There is another such cascade which starts instead from AdS-CFT applied to type II supergravity and then proceeds downward in dimension. This is displayed further below.

gauge theory induced via AdS-CFT correspondence

M-theory perspective via AdS7-CFT6F-theory perspective
11d supergravity/M-theory
$\;\;\;\;\downarrow$ Kaluza-Klein compactification on $S^4$compactificationon elliptic fibration followed by T-duality
7-dimensional supergravity
$\;\;\;\;\downarrow$ topological sector
7-dimensional Chern-Simons theory
$\;\;\;\;\downarrow$ AdS7-CFT6 holographic duality
6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT on the M5-brane with conformal invarianceM5-brane worldvolume theory
$\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ KK-compactification on Riemann surfacedouble dimensional reduction on M-theory/F-theory elliptic fibration
N=2 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory with Montonen-Olive S-duality invariance; AGT correspondenceD3-brane worldvolume theory with type IIB S-duality
$\;\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ topological twist
topologically twisted N=2 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory
$\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ KK-compactification on Riemann surface
A-model on $Bun_G$, Donaldson theory

$\,$

gauge theory induced via AdS5-CFT4
type II string theory
$\;\;\;\;\downarrow$ Kaluza-Klein compactification on $S^5$
$\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ topological sector
5-dimensional Chern-Simons theory
$\;\;\;\;\downarrow$ AdS5-CFT4 holographic duality
N=4 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory
$\;\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ topological twist
topologically twisted N=4 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory
$\;\;\;\; \downarrow$ KK-compactification on Riemann surface
A-model on $Bun_G$ and B-model on $Loc_G$, geometric Langlands correspondence

Infinite-temperature thermal field theory

With the formulation of thermal field theory via Wick rotation as a Euclidean field theory on a Riemannian manifold $X_3 \times S^1_\beta$ whose compact/periodic Euclidean time runs along a circle $S^1_\beta$ of circumference $\beta = 1/T$, the limit of infinite temperature corresponds to the limit $\beta \to 0$ in which this circle fiber shrinks away.

In terms of the thermal Euclidean field theory on $X_3 \times S^1_\beta$ therefore the infinite-temperature limit is given by Kaluaza-Klein-type dimensional reduction along this circle fiber to a 3-dimensional Euclidean field theory on $X_3$ (Ginsparg 80, Appelquist-Pisarski 81, Nadkarni 83, Jourjine 84, Nadkarni 88).

As usual with KK-reduction, some care must be exercised to ensure that the compactified theory is itself still a local field theory. Depending on how exactly one proceeds this may be subtle (Landsman 89), but there exist robust approaches (Reisz 92, Kajantie-Laine-Rummukainen-Shaposhnikov 96).

General

Reviews include

A survey of the history of the role of the KK-mechanism in theoretical physics is

• Michael Duff, Kaluza-Klein Theory in Perspective, Proc. of the Symposium: The Oskar Klein Centenary, World Scientific, Singapore. 1994. (arXiv:hep-th/9410046)

The seminal analysis of the semi-realistic KK-reductions is in

A brief discussion aimed at mathematicians of the KK-reduction of gauge fields is in

A textbook discussion in the context of supergravity is in

In

the mechanism is discussed around Section V.3.3., page 1186 in volume 2.

The discussion in the first order formulation of gravity is given in

• Rodrigo Arosa, Mauricio Romob and Nelson Zamorano, Compactification in first order gravity J.Phys.Conf.Ser.134:012013,2008 (arXiv:0705.1162)

A formalization of Kaluza-Klein compactification in perturbation theory formalized by factorization algebras with values in BV-complexes is in section 19 of

A textbook account of the geometry behind the Lorentz force in the Kaluza-Klein mechanism (the idea that geodesics on the gauge bundle project to curved trajectories on the base manifold) can be found in the introduction of chapter 1 and in chapters 9 and 10 of:

• David Bleecker, Gauge theory and variational principles, Dover publications, 1981.

An expository talk of the above material from Bleecker can be found in this talk:

Some speculative variant of KK is discussed in

In Wick-rotated thermal field theory

Discussion of Kaluza-Klein-style dimensional reduction in Wick rotated thermal field theory on a circle of compact/periodic Euclidean time $S^1_\beta$ of circumference $\beta = 1/T$ (see at infinite-temperature thermal field theory):

• Paul Ginsparg, First and second order phase transitions in gauge theories at finite temperature, Nuclear Physics B Volume 170, Issue 3, 15 December 1980, Pages 388-408 (doi:10.1016/0550-3213(80)90418-6)

• Thomas Appelquist, Robert D. Pisarski, High-temperature Yang-Mills theories and three-dimensional quantum chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 23, 2305 (1981) (doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.23.2305)

• Sudhir Nadkarni, Dimensional reduction in finite-temperature quantum chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 27, 917 (1983) (doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.27.917)

• Sudhir Nadkarni, Dimensional reduction in finite-temperature quantum chromodynamics. II, Phys. Rev. D 38, 3287 (1988) (doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.38.3287)

• Alexander N Jourjine, Quantum field theory in the infinite temperature limit, Annals of Physics Volume 155, Issue 2, July 1984, Pages 305-332 (doi:10.1016/0003-4916(84)90003-4)

• Klaas Landsman, Limitations to dimensional reduction at high temperature, Nuclear Physics B Volume 322, Issue 2, 14 August 1989, Pages 498-530 (doi:10.1016/0550-3213(89)90424-0)

• T. Reisz, Realization of dimensional reduction at high temperature, Z. Phys. C - Particles and Fields (1992) 53: 169 (doi:10.1007/BF01483886)

• Eric Braaten, Solution to the Perturbative Infrared Catastrophe of Hot Gauge Theories, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2164 (1995) (doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.74.2164)

• K. Kajantie, M. Laine, K. Rummukainen, M. Shaposhnikov, Generic rules for high temperature dimensional reduction and their application to the standard model, Nuclear Physics B Volume 458, Issues 1–2, 1 January 1996, Pages 90-136 (doi:10.1016/0550-3213(95)00549-8)

and specifically with an eye to discussion of the quark-gluon plasma in

• Jean-Paul Blaizot, Edmond Iancu, Anton Rebhan, section 2.2.4 of Thermodynamics of the high temperature quark gluon plasma, Quark–Gluon Plasma 3, pp. 60-122 (2004) (arXiv:hep-ph/0303185, spire:615570)

• Jean-Paul Blaizot, around p. 17 of Thermodynamics of the high temperature Quark-Gluon Plasma, AIP Conf. Proc. 739, 63-96 (2004) (doi:10.1063/1.1843592)