nLab soft linear logic

Idea

Soft linear logic is a version of linear logic in which the exponential modality is weakened. This has as a particular consequence that the only “definable functions” (in various senses) are computable in polynomial time?.

Definition

The usual rules of the exponential modality $!$ in (intuitionistic) linear logic are promotion, dereliction, contraction, and weakening:

$$\frac{!\Gamma\vdash A}{!\Gamma\vdash !A}(prom) \qquad \frac{\Gamma,A \vdash C}{\Gamma,!A\vdash C}(der) \qquad \frac{\Gamma,!A,!A\vdash C}{\Gamma,!A\vdash C}(ctr) \qquad \frac{\Gamma\vdash C}{\Gamma,!A\vdash C}(wk)$$

Soft linear logic is obtained by observing that these rules are equivalent to soft promotion, multiplexing, and digging:

$$\frac{\Gamma\vdash A}{!\Gamma\vdash !A}(sp) \qquad \frac{\Gamma,\overbrace{A,\dots,A}^n\vdash C}{\Gamma,!A\vdash C}(mpx) \qquad \frac{\Gamma,!!A\vdash C}{\Gamma,!A\vdash C}(dig)$$

and then removing digging. Thus, the only rules governing $!$ in soft linear logic are soft promotion and multiplexing.

Categorical semantics

Inspecting the rules for the soft $!$, we see that soft promotion says that $!$ is a lax monoidal functor (or equivalently a functor between multicategories), while multiplexing says that we have a (presumably natural) transformation $!A \to A^{\otimes n}$ for all $n$. On a non-thin category one would presumably ask for some coherence axioms on these transformations.

Intriguingly, however, the naive formula for a “cofree comonoid” on an object $A$ in a symmetric monoidal category with countable products:

$$!A = \prod_{n\in\mathbb{N}} A^{\otimes n},$$

though it does not in general define a comonoid at all, is a lax monoidal functor with transformations $!A \to A^{\otimes n}$. The latter are just the product projections, while the lax monoidal structure $!A \otimes !B \to !(A\otimes B) = \prod_n (A\otimes B)^{\otimes n}$ has components

$$!A \otimes !B = \left(\prod_n A^{\otimes n}\right)\otimes \left(\prod_n B^{\otimes n}\right) \to A^{\otimes n} \otimes B^{\otimes n} \xrightarrow{\cong} (A\otimes B)^{\otimes n}.$$

In particular, therefore, any symmetric monoidal poset with countable meets admits a modality of this form satisfying the rules of the soft exponential. For a non-thin category, one could take a further limit in an attempt to impose whatever axioms are desired of the structure on $!$. For instance, if instead of $A^{\otimes n}$ we use an appropriate equalizer, we could force permutation-invariance of the transformations $!A \to A^{\otimes n}$.

Related pages

• computational complexity
  • implicit computational complexity?
  • polynomial time?
• light linear logic?
• naive set theory?
• ultrafinitism

References

• Yves Lafont, Soft linear logic and polynomial time, Theoretical Computer Science, Volume 318, Issues 1–2, 2004, Pages 163-180, doi, ps

• Marco Gaboardi, Jean-Yves Marion, Simona Ronchi Della Rocca, Soft Linear Logic and Polynomial Complexity Classes, Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science, Volume 205, 2008, Pages 67-87, doi

• Richard McKinley, Soft Linear Set Theory, The Journal of Logic and Algebraic Programming, Volume 76, Issue 2, 2008, doi